The Star Adventurer
Mini- is it “quite possibly the most
compact and versatile camera tracking platform in the known universe.”
Star Adventurer Mini(SAM) on the left and Star Adventurer on the right. Cameras are both Canon 60Da with a Samyang 135mm lens.
Close up of Star Adventurer above
Close up of the SAM above
Dave was the first to tell me about the new SAM from Sky
Watcher. “Sam?” I queried. “Star Adventurer Mini”, he replied. Sure enough, Alan Dyer for Sky and Telescope
ran a review of the product in their December 2017 issue, and we read through his
wonderful article with anticipation. The
unit seemed complicated to me, and brought one big question to mind. Since Dave already has the Star Adventurer
(which I’ve used extensively), do we really need to get the Star Adventurer
Mini? Doesn’t it do the same thing but
in a smaller package? We were
undecided. Little did Dave know at the
time, but I ordered him one for Christmas after our conversation. It was popular and backordered, but it
arrived before the 25th. He
thanked me for the wonderful gift, and then laughingly said, “It only cost me
$150!” (Because David had to order the accessories to make it all work๐)
PRICE
So let’s
start with price. The unit itself
retails for $300, and includes the mount a ball head adapter, and a polar
alignment telescope. However the
optional accessories are important and make using it so much easier. You’ll want the latitude base ($65), and the
declination bracket ($40), and maybe the counterweight ($30). However,
the unit is useless without the DSLR control cable. And the price of that will vary with your
camera but typically anywhere from $15-$30. Also a power cord would be nice
although not critical if you go with the battery option (2- AA). Dave plans on using it on his deck which has
power, and had a power cable ($10) that would work so that wasn’t an issue. Now if you own the Star Adventurer already, then
you have all of those accessories and they will all fit the SAM unit- except for
the power cord, it is slightly different.
Dave wanted a set of accessories for both mounts because he may want to
use both of them at the same time. So if
you get the works it will cost you around $460-$475
SAM and Star Adventurer on their Pro-Am tripods.(Highly recommend these tripods.)
GETTING STARTED
A few things to understand before we go any further. SAM will not put together a time lapse for you on your camera. It will take the images, but you will need to put the images together later using a program such as Cyberlink Power Director or Time-Lapse Tool. You need a smartphone with the SAM app which was easy to install. You will also need wifi, however SAM has its own system, and you connect through the app. As per the manual let’s go through this step by step. We ran into problems getting the unit to operate (and even emailed Star Adventurer for advice) so let’s save you some time. Here’s the procedure to get you up and running quickly.
A few things you need to do first. You need a smartphone with the SAM app which
was easy to install. You will also need
wifi, however SAM has its own system, and you connect through the app. As per the manual let’s go through this step
by step. We ran into problems getting
the unit to operate (and even emailed Star Adventurer for advice) so let’s save
you some time. Here’s the procedure to
get you up and running quickly.
1)
Turn the power on the unit (small black
button). The light will be red, and then
start blinking green signaling it’s ready for the wifi setup.
2)
On the Smartphone app, go to the “Settings > WiFi Network” and click “Find Devices”. Search
for “SynScanWiFi_xxxxxx”. A small box in the lower left will tell you
that you are connected. The power light
should now be a steady green.
3)
Start simple and click on “Regular Exposure Time-lapse” on the app.
4)
According to the manual you need to put a value
in for the “Video Time Span (Hr)”,
and “Video Length (sec)” then click “Run”. Except “Run” wasn’t an option. It was grayed out so you couldn’t select it. Then
I saw the answer looking at a screen shot later in the manual.
5)
Click on “Swing
Range (deg)”. We didn’t want it to
swing for the initial test so we didn’t enable it. It must be enabled for the time-lapse to
work. If you don’t want it to swing then
enable it and put in a value of “0”.
6)
Click “RUN”.
Link: Static time lapse using SAM
REGULAR EXPOSURE TIME-LAPSE
The camera
smoothly did its magic as it took its first time lapse. One of the things I didn’t like about the
Star Adventurer is that when you did a time-lapse it would automatically move
to one side and then back to the middle and then the other side and
repeat. The amount of swing range was
preset. I found this process annoying. I didn’t like moving past my object of
interest back and forth. The SAM has a huge advantage in that you can
have it go in one direction to a set number of degrees. This gives you a lot of freedom and
creativity to set up the shot you really want.
Dave made some wonderful time-lapse videos that were smooth and impressive.
Link: Panorama done with Sam and a Canon T6i
Long
exposure time-lapse, Astro time lapse and astrophotography are next, but we
need some clear nights in this cloudy and soggy winter we’re having. Stay tuned.
When the weather gets better we’ll have more to share!
Update 3/13/18
Long Exposure Time Lapse
The next step in the manual was to try a long exposure time lapse. The SAM app for this part of the article was basically the same as the regular time lapse above. The difference was in length of exposure. In the case of the links you will see below I used a 25 second exposure with a 1 second space between exposures. The swing range used was 150 degrees in the first link to 170 degrees in the second and the time picked was 9 hours in the first one and 10 hours for the second one. The swing rate was 1 which means the SAM module will move through the # of degrees picked and then will stop. If I had picked a swing rate of 2 the SAM would have moved through the # of degrees and then would have come back the other way to the starting point to finish. You can also pick whether you want it to go clockwise or counterclockwise as you will see in the links below. When you import those values the SAM app determines the number of photos taken and the # of degrees per hour. Once this is done you turn on the SAM, which creates it's own wifi, and change the wifi setting on your mobile device to access the SAM and connect. Once connected you push "Run" and SAM does the rest. The results can be seen in the links below.
Link: SAM Long Exposure Time Lapse 9 hours
Link: SAM Long Exposure 10 hours/170 degree panning
Update 3/18/18
Before going to the astrophotography part of the manual I decided to do one more long exposure of 11 hours and a 180 degree panning. Also, I decided to try my Astronomik CLS light pollution filter in the Canon T6i.
I have been remiss in showing the phone app screens and have included them for the video in the link below. They show that the exposure was 25 secs with a 1 sec delay between. The pan was 180 degrees with a 1 swing rate which means SAM will rotate in one direction from start to finish. The length of time chosen was 11 hours. Also, I chose SAM to move counterclockwise. SAM will then figure out the rest of the values based on what you imput.
Status can be checked at any time.
Red screen is the night mode screen. White will show in daylight.
Update 5/17/18
ASTRO TIME-LAPSE
The first thing you will be scratching your head about is what is the difference between the Astro Time-lapse and Astrophotography modes? Answer: The Astro Time-lapse allows you to keep the same foreground image while the stars move, so you want to use a wide field lens. In Astrophotography mode you are tracking the object of interest so you want a narrow field lens. Both need to be polar aligned. We’ll deal with astrophotography in the next section. The better question is why do you need the Astro Time-lapse mode at all? Wouldn’t it be easier to just set up the tripod without polar aligning it? The traditional method is simply setting up the tripod and framing your horizon, and then set the intervalometer on your camera to about 30-40 seconds or whatever your camera/ lens combination can take without trailing, and you’re done. You could do this, but the Astro Time-lapse is SO much better. The idea here is to be able to take a longer exposure without trailing so it needs to be polar aligned. So instead of a 30 second exposure how about 60 or 90 seconds? Think about how much brighter the foreground objects will be and the depth of the star field or Milky Way. The problem here is that the horizon objects will move slightly with each image. SAM counteracts this by automatically returning back to its point of origin for each picture thereby leaving the horizon image in sharp focus. The results are beautiful, so let’s get started.
Polar Alignment
On the top of the unit, next to the power button, are two small peep sites for a visual view of Polaris. It’s called the polar viewfinder (page 20 in the manual). On the Star Adventure Mini Console App under POLAR CLOCK UTILITY you will find at the bottom of the screen a button to select for LIGHT ON and OFF. This puts a red light on each peephole site. Simply center Polaris in the two peep sites and you have a coarse alignment.
The manual says that the peep hole site is fine for applications for up to 30 seconds with a short focal length lens; for longer exposures you want to use the polar finder scope and illuminator. This comes standard with SAM. To set it up, screw off the back cover and you’ll see the hole where the polar scope slides into.
It’s a bit of a tight fit, but it should be snug. Be certain to turn the polar finder so that the orientation matches that on the POLAR CLOCK UTILITY, namely with the number 6 facing straight down.
The illuminator is attached to an adapter that fits snugly in the slot on the "declination bracket." It should be in line with the polar scope as seen in the photo.
The problem I had is that it wasn’t snug. If this happens to you put some tape over the adapter “feet” to make a better fit. Dave purchased a white adapter for this purpose for his Star Adventurer, and that works well so I used that. When ready, turn the illuminator on and align Polaris carefully to match the app by turning the altitude and azimuth screws. Turn off the illuminator, and you are ready to go. The polar finder can be left in the unit.
SAM Console and Camera Setup
The camera I used was a Canon 60Da with a light pollution filter. It was set to an ISO of 800. The lens was a Rokinon 14mm at f/2.8. You want to be certain that you are shooting jpegs only and not jpegs+RAW images. This will make life much easier when you make the time lapse. Also be certain the long exposure noise reduction (dark frame) is turned off. If desired shoot 10 dark frames (leave the lens cap on) at the same exposure as the light frame. You can then create a master dark and subtract those from the light frames during processing.
On the Star Adventure Mini Console App turn on the wifi under SETTINGS and then choose ASTRO TIME-LAPSE. The settings I used are shown in the image. I set an exposure time of 60 seconds and 400 photos. This would take 7.24 hours, but I wanted a dusk to dawn scenario.
Make certain that the battery is fully charged on SAM or that you have it plugged into an external power source. You might also want to use Dave's Dew System if this will be an issue during the night. See his blog for details on this simple, but very effective dew prevention system. Click RUN on the app and watch the first image come in. Press STOP. It's critical that you check your first image for focus, landscape setup, and brightness. Zoom in to look for any signs of star trailing- there should be none. You may want to experiment with a different exposure time or ISO setting. Repeat this process until you're satisfied with your image. Erase all of these"test images" and start with a clean card. It's time. Hit RUN and let it go. You can always check the status on the app or even have the wifi turned off. the unit will still continue to run until all of the images have been taken.
Results
Remember that it doesn't take a finished time-lapse for you; it merely collects the data. You have to assemble the time-lapse in a different computer program. The finished product here was taken in Pennsylvania in a rural/suburban setting.
Link below: If you have a smart TV and can cast from your phone or laptop to the YouTube app on the TV it's much better a view of any of these links in this article.
Night at the Observatory
Astrophotography
Once you've experienced the time lapse features of the SAM unit you are ready to move onto the astrophotography stage.SETUP
The concept of SAM is for travel, so I went to the Mars Desert Research Station in Utah, to do some deep sky astrophotography using a 135 mm lens. Afterwards, I went to Guernsey State Park in Wyoming to watch and record the Perseid meteor shower using a 14mm lens. Details on the setup are as follows.
MARS DESERT RESEARCH STATION
CAMERA: Canon 60Da
LENS: Samyang f/2 135mm
FILTER: Canon APSC Astro filter
ISO: 1000
EXPOSURE: 50 seconds
DARK FRAME: YES
GUERNSEY STATE PARK
CAMERA: Canon 60Da
LENS: Rokinon f2.8 14mm
FILTER: None
ISO: 1600
EXPOSURE 60 seconds
DARK FRAME: No
The image above shows the setup for the SAM unit which is also the same for the Astro-Time Lapse. Notice I have it connected to a large battery. Originally I preferred this over using disposable batteries in the unit, but I've tried it both ways. SAM uses two AA batteries, and I found that they would last two and a half nights (all night long) with no issues. On the large external battery the USB charge was so slight that in one evening the recharge time on the large battery was only 10 minutes. if you are travelling you want to keep it simple. Use the AA batteries where there is no power, and the power cord where there is.
POLAR ALIGNMENT
I performed the same polar alignment as with the Astro Time Lapse. Begin by leveling the tripod and using the polar scope and Polar Utility included with SAM. Please see the section of this article under Astro-Time Lapse for specific details. I could use the Pole Master, but I'm not planning on taking several minute exposures or guided images; it's not necessary. The polar alignment sequence only takes minutes, and is appropriate for the task.
SAM Console Setup
- Power up the SAM unit.
- Connect it to the virtual wifi.
- Perform your polar alignment using the polar utility app in SAM.
- Click on Astrophotography.
- Set the exposure time and number of images. Start with 1 image until you are satisfied you have the correct focus and exposure time.
- Click RUN.
In these fairly remote locations there is no internet, but this isn't a problem for SAM. It creates its own virtual wifi address so I can still control it using my smartphone or in this case my tablet. Once SAM is hooked up I don't recommend using the device to do other tasks. Set it and let it go. even so, I did notice the virtual wifi dropped several times through the course of the observing session the first night, but none the second. This is not a problem. Once SAM begins to run then it will continue to complete its assigned sequence regardless of the wifi. The wifi is only needed to stop the run or check the status, and it's simple to reconnect by touching the internet status on the bottom left of the page.
RESULTS
At the Mars Desert Research Station I started with 2 minute exposures, which is long with the 135 focal length lens that I used. However, only slight trailing was observed. I discovered that only 50 seconds was ideal with the f/2 system. The quality of the images matched my friends who were using a Celestron AVX mount and longer exposures to guide their camera (although they did have different focal length lenses). I believe that the joy of this system is the simplicity and fast setup. I'll be honest- I was busy with other tasks that evening as I was testing a robotic observatory for the Mars Society. Every now and then I would simply point the camera and take a 50 second exposure. The results were amazing considering the amount of time I actually spent setting it up.
At the Mars Desert Research Station I started with 2 minute exposures, which is long with the 135 focal length lens that I used. However, only slight trailing was observed. I discovered that only 50 seconds was ideal with the f/2 system. The quality of the images matched my friends who were using a Celestron AVX mount and longer exposures to guide their camera (although they did have different focal length lenses). I believe that the joy of this system is the simplicity and fast setup. I'll be honest- I was busy with other tasks that evening as I was testing a robotic observatory for the Mars Society. Every now and then I would simply point the camera and take a 50 second exposure. The results were amazing considering the amount of time I actually spent setting it up.
At Guernsey State Park the goal was meteors so I wanted a wide field lens. I also didn't want to use an automatic dark frame fro each image since I could "lose" a meteor during that down time. If desired, you can take a dark frame at the beginning and the end of your observing session, and subtract them from the images in Autostakkert during processing.
I set the system up and let it run continuously until 5 AM. During that time I was elsewhere counting meteors visually. There was absolutely no prioblem with tracking, and it doesn't require any "baby-sitting". So how close does it track? Here's a result of 91 images stacked directly on top of each other using the Star Trails program.
The results are rather impressive for such an easy setup with minimal polar alignment. I wasn't able to catch a nice fireball that evening, but the following image does show a nice meteor just above the Andromeda Galaxy.
SUMMARY
You can read an article on both the Star Adventurer and Star Adventurer Mini on this blog. If you had to choose which do you get? That depends on your goals. If you want to accommodate a small refractor then you want the Star Adventurer. The SAM unit is simply too small to handle that kind of weight. SAM is ideal for a camera and a lens (even a long focal length one).
Both do time lapses, but I prefer the SAM for this application. You can set the exposure, slew speed and direction of travel to your specifications rather than using the presets with the Star Adventurer. This makes SAM much more versatile in this regard.
if you want a small portable, reliable mount that is fast to set up and accurate to use , then both would work, and all of the components for either model (save the tripod) will fit easily into your camera bag.
Dave is kind enough to let me field test his equipment in exchange for a write-up on his blog. I have to say, after using both units, I have to personally buy the SAM. there can be no greater accolade for a piece of equipment then that.
Hi, Based on this article, I understand that you know very well the star adventurer mini, Actually I own one for using the astro-timelapse feature. I met some issues which is like a bug... the exposure time is not constant... / for instance requesting 10s, I get fluctuation around ( Mainly 10s, but some values from 9,8s to 10,3s and time time time 6,2s 8,4s 11s .... / Have you checked this point / Thank you
ReplyDeleteI have had that same thing. It usually is just the program adapting to something like a change number of exposures or time wanted.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete